Pass in Review
an inspection of the literature
A book may be as great a thing as a battle.
Benjamin Disraeli, Earl of Beaconsfield
Life Among the Apache
by John C. Cremony; Bison Books, University of Nebraska Press,
Lincoln, NE (©1868; repr 1985)
Cremony's book is not alone in the genre of 19th
century memoirs recounting life and experiences with indigenous
people of the Great Plains and deserts of the diminishing western
frontier, yet it is a unique work by an intelligent man who
obviously had both a formal education and sadly uncommon common
sense.
Though describing a number of battles with Apaches and other
tribes that Cremony actually participated in, including one hand-to-hand fight, won with a knife, the book does not deal as much
with war per se as it does with elements too often
overlooked in warfare, particularly when one is either aligned
with and/or fighting against people quite different, ethnically
and mentally, than oneself. Cremony did both, and penned an
intriguing account in which he forthrightly expresses his
disagreement with U.S. government policies and tactics in the
Indian Wars.
He first served with a U.S. Boundary Commission in 1849 and into
the early 1850s, and later, in the early to mid 1860s, with U.S.
cavalry elements assigned to first defeat Confederate forces in
the southwest, and then to secure areas of Arizona and New Mexico
subjected to Apache attacks. Anyone serving in Viet Nam –
or Iraq or Afghanistan – particularly in an advisory role,
will stumble across parallels of their own experiences, and
perhaps wonder why this book is not included on recommended
reading lists for today's military servicemembers.
The book clearly reveals Cremony's mental acuity, maturity and
astute judgment, and almost seems too good to be true, and
perhaps the product of an author with more imagination than
direct experience. Yet a cursory search revealed no reason to
doubt Cremony's credentials or character, and the Bison Press
imprint carries great credibility, hence the book is taken at
face value.
A recurring theme is injected, bluntly and directly, in the
preface:
"Our government has expended millions of dollars, in driblets,
since the acquisition of California, in efforts to reduce the
Apaches and Navajos, who occupy that extensive belt of country
... but we are as far from success to-day as we were twenty years
ago. The reason is obvious. We have never striven to make
ourselves intellectually acquainted with these tribes. Nearly all
that relates to them is as uncertain and indefinite to our
comprehension as that which obtains in the center of Africa."
This point is convincingly reinforced throughout the book,
sometimes sounding eerily like the complaints of district or
province advisors in Viet Nam, and perhaps those now serving in
Afghanistan or Iraq.
Cremony admits to not understanding what was in front of him,
visible to the eye, during his Boundary Commission tour,
and it is only years later, while in charge of Apaches placed in
a government camp in what is now Fort Sumner, New Mexico, that he
goes beyond the cultural curtain, the one-way mirror through
which indigenous people viewed interlopers with much greater
clarity than they themselves were observed. Yet Cremony does not
go native and is not blindly mesmerized by what some saw
as Rousseauian noble savages. He bluntly describes, and
with clinical candor, practices he views, with justification, as
being cruel and unworthy of emulation, to include torturing
captives and mutilating bodies of dead enemies. Acknowledging the
Apache tendency to view the world in eternally combative terms,
of inexorable enmity between the other, be they whites
or other tribes, Cremony set out to learn from his Apache
charges. Rather than view them with contempt and arrogance, which
the Apache could smell in a second, Cremony employed a simple yet
effective technique: he asked Apaches about their language, their
ambush tactics, their hunting techniques, their burial practices,
and other aspects of their lives. In the course of this learning
process, he also learned their language and compiled a study of
Apache linguistics that was later submitted to the Smithsonian
for future scholars to examine.
This effort was in part motivated by the scorn Cremony held for
whites who simply viewed the Apaches, and all native Americans,
as ignorant savages incapable of rational thinking. He viewed
this as both stupid in its own right and also leading to counter-productive policies which prolonged troubles on the frontier, and
promoted more violence and death. His views are succinctly
spelled out in relevant passages throughout the book, among which
is his observation that
"In our dealings with the Indian tribes we have quite underrated
their abilities, and in this we have demonstrated our own
stupidity. The vanity and self-conceit of civilized and educated
men are never more stilted than when brought in contact with
savage races. Such persons are prone to address the Indian with a
smirk or patronizing air which is very offensive, and would never
be used toward an equal."
Ethnocentric myopia also contributed to bumbling by high ranking
territorial commanders and general officers who were simply out
of their league:
"Whenever an intelligent and well conceived movement has been
concerted within the power of the limited force in Arizona,
official stupidity has invariably disconcerted and paralyzed its
efficiency. ... Personally, my regard for that officer [General
McDowell, one-time commander in Arizona] as a gentleman is very
sincere; but it may be doubted if the army register contains the
name of another so wholly, so utterly incapable of comprehending
Indian nature and the requirements of Indian warfare."
Many who served in Viet Nam will cringe in recalling similarly
ill-equipped superior officers, people who, for some reason,
simply could not grasp, could not relate, to what was around
them. Just as they will relate to Cremony's indictment of
careerism among inept Indian agents, and an equally
withering damnation of the fort-building fetish, in contrast to
the need for vigilant cavalry constantly on the move.
The book is delightfully free of clichés and the typical
cast of standard characters frequently encountered in movies or
shallow histories. Some Apache individuals are depicted as the
dignified people they were; others as the duplicitous poltroons
they showed themselves to be. The de rigueur caricature
of idiot Indian-hating whites is almost absent, aside from brief
mention of sociopathic scum on the frontier (some of whom are
reported to meet a cruel – and deserved – fate), and
instead the reader encounters mention of Doctor David Wooster, a
physician who befriends and is respected by the Pima and Maricopa
tribes, and a Captain Updegraff, who allows Cremony to lead
Apaches on an emergency hunt to relieve food shortages at Fort
Sumner. Conversely, the noble savage myth takes a
beating, showing that Apaches were just as capable of infantile
selfishness as are many contemporary people described in
Dear Abby columns. An old warrior, formerly a
valiant fighter, is described as ignored and neglected by the
tribe. Cremony also discerned that Apache females most admired
the shiftiest thieves and con men rather than the tribe's less-wealthy quiet and humble hunters and warriors. This all changed,
of course, whenever external threats upped the value of warriors,
but once normalcy had been restored, the horse-thieves once again
enthralled tribal maidens. Kipling probably wrote something on
that topic.
While Cremony's insight, mature character and quest for knowledge
are engaging elements in this work, the book also functions on
another level as an adventure story, featuring treks across the
burning – or freezing – southwest, hot pursuit by
hostile Yuma Indians across the barren sand dunes, a later stand-off with the same Yumas along the Colorado River, Apache
ambushes, contentious negotiations to free Mexican
slaves from Apaches, and even a bloody engagement in which U.S.
Cavalry forces joined with Apaches to recapture sheep stolen by
marauding Navahos, leaving scores of dead. Once again, parallels
with later wars are found, illustrating that the tactical
principles remain the same, discounting differences in weaponry.
A rare Apache night attack is broken up by alert sentries
positioned on perimeter listening posts , the same kind of LPs
commonly employed in Viet Nam. Overnight laagers are located
beyond range of Indian weapons, and with clear fields of fire all
around, similar to practices employed at times by mechanized
infantry units in Viet Nam. Superior firepower is applied to
break up a deadly Apache ambush in a narrow defile, not in the
form of a 105mm main gun nor quad-.50 machine guns, but with a
small 12-pounder field piece brought to bear on Apaches concealed
on the high ground.
Physical hardships are almost blandly mentioned, quite
understandable given the fact that life itself, absent central
heating, indoor plumbing, and air conditioning, was a constant
ordeal in those days. Oddly, Cremony only once mentions the famed
blistering heat of the Arizona and New Mexico desert summers, and
has more to say about almost unbearable cold encountered during
winter operations.
Altogether, this is a memorable and edifying book, all the more
valuable because of the author's maturity and inquisitive nature,
character traits leading him to comprehension of Apache ways, and
a degree of respect from the Apaches themselves. It is not too
much of a stretch to suggest this book should be on contemporary
military reading lists, particularly for those who may be
deployed to Afghanistan or Iraq, and who might be impelled to
develop some linguistic and cross-cultural skills which, if
Cremony's account and later similar experiences in Viet Nam or
Laos are any indication, will enhance performance and play a role
in the important subordinate mission of connecting, on the
underlying human level, with indigenous peoples of these and
other countries to which Americans may be assigned.
Minor shortcomings exist. The edition reviewed had no maps, the
inclusion of which would be welcome and beneficial. Nor is there
an introduction providing more information on Cremony's life and
education, or perhaps similar works. There is no index, nor any
drawings, if only to illustrate terrain features and varying
topography of the southwest. Several editions are available over
the internet, and readers, particularly those familiar with the
region's terrain and climate, are encouraged to get an edition
with Carl Hantman's cover art, Abandoned, an
intriguing piece of art portraying an Apache band, alert to
something unseen, gazing into the distance from a desert hill.
Hantman visually captures, through astute placement of shadows,
showing high sun elevation in summer, and mid-day heat haze of
the southwest desert, the feel of the southwest's harsh
yet haunting desert mountain country, while depicting the very
same tough, durable Apaches Cremony describes in this memorable
work.
contributed by William S. Laurie
|